Charles Fox in the platters guide has scored the following for each vintage respectively.

2020 Vintage Rose – Tim Atkin 93 Points 2024 Report | Gilbert & Gaillard Gold

2018 Cipher – Blanc de Noirs  – Tim Atkin 91 Points 2024 Report | Gilbert & Gaillard Double Gold

Reserve Brut 4.5 Stars (Platters 2024) | Tim Atkin 92 Points 2023 Report | Gilbert & Gaillard Double Gold

2017 Vintage Brut – Gilbert & Gaillard Double Gold

2017 Cipher – Blanc de Noir 4.5 Stars | Tim Atkin 93 Points

2017 Blanc de Blanc 4.5 Stars | Tim Atkin 92 Points

2016 Coeur de Cuvee 4.5 Stars | Tim Atkin 92 Points

Reserve Brut 4.5 Stars (Platters 2023) | Tim Atkin 90 Points 2022 Report

Reserve Gold  4.5 Stars Double Gold Gilbert & Gaillard | Tim Atkin 89 Points

Reserve Rose 4.5 Stars | Tim Atkin 88 Points | Gilbert & Gaillard Gold

2016 Vintage Brut – 4.5 Stars | Tim Atkin Not Entered

2016 Blanc de Blancs -5 Stars | Tim Atkin 93 Points | Michelangelo Gold

2015 Cipher – 5 Stars | Michelangelo Gold

2015 Vintage Rose – 4.5 Stars | Tim Atkin 91 Points | 91 Points Sommeliers Choice Awards – San Francisco

2015 Vintage Brut 4.5 Stars | Michelangelo Gold | Tim Atkin 92 Points

2013 Vintage Rose 4.5 Stars | Michelangelo Gold | Tim Atkin 91 Points

2013 Cipher – 4.5 Stars | Michelangelo Gold | Tim Atkin 94 Points

Reserve Rose 4.5 Stars | Michelangelo Platinum | Tim Atkin 93 Points

Reserve Brut 4 Stars| Michelangelo Platinum | Tim Atkin 92 Points

2013 Brut – 4.5 Stars | Tim Atkin 93 Points

2013 Blanc de Blancs – 4.5 Stars | Tim Atkin 93 Points

2012 Cipher – 4.5 Stars | Tim Atkin 96 Points

2012 Brut Rose – 4.5 Stars | Tim Atkin 93 Points

2012 Brut – 4.5 Stars

2011 Cipher – 4.5 Stars

2011 Brut Rose – 4.5 Stars

2011 Brut – 4 Stars

2010 Brut Rose – 4.5 Stars

2010 Brut – 4 Stars